Susie's Sub Shop

Discover Susie's Sub Shop in Columbus, OH, for delicious Italian subs, meatball, sausage, roast beef, and pizza subs. Enjoy affordable, flavorful meals at 3739 Karl Rd. Call us today!

Welcome to Susie's Sub Shop

Signature Dining Experience

Susie's Sub Shop
Susie's Sub Shop
Susie's Sub Shop
Susie's Sub Shop

Located at 3739 Karl Rd, Columbus, OH, Susie's Sub Shop is the go-to spot for sandwich lovers and pizza enthusiasts alike. This little slice of heaven serves up an impressive variety of Italian subs, pizza, and more, all at prices that won't break the bank. Whether you’re craving a hearty meatball sub or a classic pizza, this establishment delivers satisfaction with each bite. The warm and inviting atmosphere welcomes patrons of all ages, making it a perfect destination for family dinners or evening takeouts. With a peak popularity that hits 100% on Fridays at 5 PM, Susie's knows how to bring the community together over great food.

Location & Contact

Address

3739 Karl Rd, Columbus, OH 43224, United States

Phone

+1 614-261-7827

Social Media

About

Susie's Sub Shop
Susie's Sub Shop
Susie's Sub Shop
Susie's Sub Shop

Susie's Sub Shop stands out in Columbus, OH, as a beloved local eatery that specializes in pizza and subs. What began as a small neighborhood establishment has grown into a culinary landmark among locals. With a finger on the pulse of community needs, Susie's consistently adapts its menu to include customer favorites like the Italian sub and hearty meatball sandwich. Frequent visitors know that Susie doesn’t just make food; she crafts experiences that bring friends and families together over great meals.

The restaurant operates six days a week, closing on Sundays, making it a staple for weekday lunches and dinners. Busy professionals and students alike flock to Susie’s, especially during peak lunch hours, where the average popularity reaches 32.2%. From meatball subs to a variety of pies, the menu caters to both quick lunches and leisurely dinners. The commitment to quality shines through in each freshly prepared dish. Regulars often highlight the generous helpings that make dining here, satisfying and affordable.

The atmosphere within Susie's fosters a sense of belonging, encouraging customers to linger over their meals and share stories. The decor reflects a casual yet warm setting, perfect for those lazy afternoons or lively Friday evenings when the shop is bustling with activity. Susie's takes pride in community involvement, frequently hosting local events and special promotions that further ground its place as a neighborhood favorite.

Another hallmark of Susie’s Sub Shop is the emphasis on customer feedback. Menu adjustments often arise from direct input, ensuring that the offerings resonate with the clientele. This responsiveness not only builds trust but also attracts new customers eager to experience what all the buzz is about. Susie's is not just a meal stop; it's a cherished part of the neighborhood landscape, where every visit feels like dining with family.

Work Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday3-9 PM

Susie's Sub Shop is known for its diverse menu, featuring both classic and innovative offerings. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes and fresh ingredients, especially in their highly rated Italian subs and pizza. The restaurant boasts a total of 109 menu items, ensuring something for every palate, including vegetarian options and special rolls. Customers appreciate the affordability with an overall average price of $11.71.

Speedy service during peak hours ensures that even during busy times, diners don’t have to wait long for their meals. The staff are friendly and ready to help, making every visit enjoyable.

The shop also offers takeout for those dining at home or on the go. Expect a lively vibe, especially during dinner rush hours, where excitement fills the air and the aroma of freshly baked pizza tantalizes the senses.

Susie's Sub Shop

The exterior of Susie's Sub Shop sets a welcoming tone for visitors. The quaint, approachable storefront features a vibrant sign that captures the eye and hints at the delicious offerings inside. Ample parking makes it easy for customers to swing by, whether for a quick meal or a leisurely dinner.

The outdoor seating is perfect for enjoying the fresh air, especially during warmer months. The vibe is relaxed and friendly, echoing the spirit of the Columbus community. Locals often gather outside to exchange stories and share a meal under the sun, making it a lively part of the local culture.

Customer Reviews

The Italian sub the husband got was amazing. He loved it. I got the pizza roll. Not a horrible price for 5 smallish pizza rolls. They were flavorless. A little garlic butter or seasoning on them would of made all the difference. Great lady. Great service.

M
Mildred M.

I stumbled across an article on the interwebs listing the best sandwiches in every state amd Susieswas the Ohio pick. My boyfriend and I were driving through so we stopped to eat in. More of a takeout spot, but the dining room was clean and comfortable. Service was very friendly. I had the 8" meatball sub with 4 huge meatballs and my boyfriend had 8" sausage sub, and both were pure toasty, cheesy, saucy perfection. 10/10 would detour again. Reminds me of my favorite old school sub shop back home.

M
Missy K.

I missed my exit heading back home and saw this shop when turning around. And I made a point to come back when I was in the Columbus area. I ordered the Big John sub and the Italian sub, both 16" and they were huge! One of the best subs I've ever had. I'll be bringing the family with me next time!

C
Christopher E.

Want just some of the best home town locally operated and owned pizza? Look no further. It's just a damn good pizza. I like to treat myself atleast twice a month as the shop is just up the street from my work. It's not Dijorno, it's not Pizza Hut, it's just a damn good pizza. And add the Big John sub to the order? You and a few buddies will have some great chow for lunch or dinner and feel fat, happy, and sassy afterwards. Try it and support local vs. Corporate, you'll be glad you did.

J
Joe S.

We tried this place tonight. It was very good! We had a 16" pizza sub, a 16" garlic bread, and a 16" pizza that was half pepperoni, extra cheese, and half pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese. The cheese, pepperoni, sauce, onions, and crust were great! The sausage was decent. The garlic bread was good. The pizza sub was good. We'll visit again.

S
Shane J.

Always had good food here.

A
Aaron